The letters "LLC" on wood blocks on a computer

Who Should Form an LLC? 

An LLC usually makes sense once your business has real customers, real revenue, or real risk. It separates your personal assets from your business, as long as you run it correctly.

You should seriously consider an LLC if you are:

  • A sole proprietor with steady clients or income
  • An independent contractor working in a trade
  • An owner of one or more rental properties
  • Going into business with one or more partners

An LLC alone does not lower your taxes. Tax savings come from choices like an S-corporation election, covered below.

    When You Probably Don’t Need an LLC Yet

    If you are still testing an idea, you can usually wait. Forming an LLC too early adds filing fees and paperwork before you know the business will last.

    Common examples include:

    • Mowing a few neighbors’ lawns to see if a lawn care business could grow
    • Occasionally selling a hobby craft to friends or acquaintances
    • Driving for a rideshare or delivery app on the side

    Rideshare and delivery drivers may not need an LLC, but check your coverage first. Platform insurance typically applies only during active trips, so review your personal auto policy with your insurance agent.

      How an LLC Protects Your Personal Assets

      The main reason to form an LLC is liability protection. It keeps business debts and lawsuits from reaching your personal assets.

      As a sole proprietor, you and your business are legally the same. If the business is sued, a court judgment can reach your home, car, and personal savings.

      A properly run LLC is a separate legal entity. In most cases, a claim against the business is limited to business assets. That protection is not automatic, though, as the next section explains.

       

      • You must operate your LLC as a separate business.
      • You must have an operating agreement. An operating agreement is just a document that states how your LLC will be operated, what kind of business it is in, who the owners are, how money is contributed, etc. It defines the way that your LLC will operate and should be drafted by an attorney.

      What It Takes to Keep That Protection

      Filing with the state is only the first step. Paying the [STATE] filing fee of [FEE AMOUNT] creates the LLC, but how you run it determines whether the protection holds up.

      To keep your personal assets separate:

      • Keep finances separate. Open a business bank account and never mix personal and business funds.
      • Have a written operating agreement. It spells out who owns the LLC, how money is contributed and distributed, and how decisions are made. [Law firm: “Our attorneys can draft one for you.” CPA firm: “We recommend having an attorney draft it.”]
      • Sign contracts in the LLC’s name. Make it clear customers and vendors are dealing with the business, not you personally.
      • Stay in good standing. File your [STATE] annual report and pay any annual fees on time.
      • Carry adequate insurance. An LLC does not replace general liability or umbrella coverage.

      LLC vs. Corporation: Flexibility

      An additional reason for forming an LLC is for the flexibility it can offer. There are other types of business entities out there, such as corporations, S-corporations, and partnerships.

      Corporations have certain formalities that you must follow. You must have shareholder and board of director meetings at least once a year where you take minutes and keep formal record of that.

      What does that look like if you are a single owner? What does the shareholder meeting look like? Those are things that you are required by law to do. With an LLC, it is not explicitly required to do that.

      In an LLC you define how you operate your company for the most part. You define your formalities whereas corporations have formalities written for them that must be followed.

      Profit Distributions

      Forming an LLC also offers flexibility in taking distributions from your business. If you have multiple owners of the LLC, let’s say there are two owners, and it is a 50 – 50 ownership situation. But in this scenario one owner does most of the work and the other owner simply contributes the collateral for the business.

      It is likely that owner that does most of the work will take more of the profit distributions than the one that just contributes the collateral. So even though it is 50 – 50 ownership, the working owner can take an 80% distribution and the investing owner can take the remaining 20% distribution.

      If you were a corporation and it was 50 – 50 ownership, then the distributions must be taken as 50 – 50. There is no getting around that.

      Flexibility in Tax Treatment for LLCs

      And the last point of flexibility is the way that you can choose to be taxed.

      By default, an LLC is taxed the same way as a sole proprietor. Or if there are two or more owners, it is taxed in the same way as a partnership.

      However, you can elect to have your LLC taxed as a corporation. It could be a C-corporation or an S-corporation.

      This gives you the legal benefits and protections of having an LLC and the benefits of having an S-corporation tax election.

      Does an LLC Change Your Taxes?

      No. Forming an LLC by itself does not change how your business is taxed.

      By default, the IRS treats an LLC as follows:

      • One owner: a “disregarded entity,” taxed like a sole proprietorship on your personal return
      • Two or more owners: taxed as a partnership

      Either way, owners who work in the business generally pay self-employment tax on their share of profits. That tax is 15.3%, covering Social Security (12.4%, up to an annual wage limit) and Medicare (2.9%). To change that picture, you need a tax election such as S-corporation status.

      Should You Elect S-Corp Status?

      An S-corp election can reduce self-employment tax for profitable businesses, but it is not right for everyone.

      How the savings work. As an S-corp owner who works in the business, you pay yourself a reasonable salary through payroll. Payroll taxes apply to that salary. Profits you take above it as distributions are not subject to self-employment tax.

      What it costs. The election adds payroll processing, a separate business tax return, and more bookkeeping. Some states also tax S-corporations at the entity level. For businesses with modest profits, these costs can outweigh the savings.

      How to elect. You file IRS Form 2553 to tell the IRS your LLC will be taxed as an S-corporation. Deadlines and eligibility rules apply, so it is best handled by your CPA.

      Frequently Asked Questions

      Does an LLC protect me if I don't keep business and personal money separate?

      Possibly not. Mixing funds is one of the most common reasons courts disregard an LLC’s protection and hold owners personally liable.

      How much does it cost to form an LLC in Colorado?

      To form an LLC in Colorado, the mandatory state filing fee is $50, which you pay when submitting your Articles of Organization online.

      Can a single-member LLC elect S-corp taxation?

      Yes. Single-member and multi-member LLCs can both elect S-corp status by filing Form 2553, as long as they meet IRS eligibility rules.

      Do I need an LLC for each rental property?

      Not necessarily. Separate LLCs offer the most protection, while one LLC is simpler. The right choice depends on your risk tolerance and how many properties you own.

      Is an LLC better than a corporation?

      For most small businesses, an LLC offers similar liability protection with fewer formalities and more flexibility. Businesses planning to raise outside investment may prefer a corporation.

      Important Considerations Before Choosing S-Corp Election

      You will find that S-corporations pay significantly fewer taxes than sole proprietors, LLC’s, and partnerships. This is because profits from an S-corporation are not subject to self-employment tax. Self-employment tax is 15.3% of your earnings which is quite significant.

      There are a lot of other things to consider before you choose an S-corporation election. You have got to make sure it is right for you and your business. I highly recommend that you talk to a professional, an attorney or a CPA. Make sure it is right for your business.

      We are here to help. If you need assistance in determining whether or not to set up an LLC for your business or if you are already an LLC and are wondering if you should be making an S-corporation election, we’d love to help. Reach out to us at nguyencpas.com or support@nguyencpas.com and schedule a complimentary consultation with one of our advisors.